Updated · By Pete Bromfield, former Head of Maths with IB examining experience

IA idea · Simulation & Monte Carlo methods

Does the best team win? Knockout cups versus leagues

AI SLAI HLAA SLAA HL Solid Also in: Sport, Voting & game theory, Probability

Research question

Using match-win probabilities estimated from real results, how often does the strongest team win a knockout cup compared with a round-robin league, and how many rounds or legs does a cup need to be as reliable as a league?

Make it yours, then agree it with your teacher.

Next step: plan this IA free — the planner opens with this question filled in. For feedback on your own draft, the IA package (€39 once) gives you 5 AI feedback credits and every annotated exemplar in full.

Why it makes a good exploration

Fans argue about whether cups are 'lotteries'. Estimating win probabilities from real data and simulating thousands of tournaments gives a numerical answer and a fair comparison of formats.

The mathematics you'll need

  • Estimating match probabilities from results
  • Exact probability for small knockout brackets (tree diagrams)
  • Simulation of full tournaments
  • Comparing proportions; HL: confidence intervals
  • Effect of seeding and two-legged ties

Where the data comes from

Download a season of results from Football-Data.co.uk or a sport you follow and estimate team strengths.

  • Football-Data.co.uk — Match results, shots, cards and bookmaker odds for 25+ seasons of European leagues, CSV.
  • Desmos graphing calculator — Free graphing and regression (y₁ ~ ax₁ + b) — fit models to your data and show residuals.

Real data for this idea

  1. Primary source: Football-Data.co.uk: Results and odds files. Choose a league and season; FTHG, FTAG and FTR give the goals and the result. Licence: No reuse licence found: link to it and cite it, and do not republish the files.

There is no open reuse licence for these figures: copy only the values you analyse into your own table, and cite the page and the date. Links checked October 2026; we link to the data and never copy it. More free data sets.

A possible outline

  1. Estimate win, draw and loss probabilities for each pairing from data.
  2. Calculate exactly for a four-team knockout.
  3. Simulate an eight- or sixteen-team cup and a league.
  4. Compare how often the best team wins each format.
  5. Reflect on the probability model and home advantage.

Pitfalls that cost marks

  • Probabilities that ignore draws or home advantage without comment.
  • Too few simulated tournaments.
  • No exact check for a small case.

Showing personal engagement

  • Use your own league or sport.
  • Ask whether your school tournament format is fair.
  • Design the fairest format that fits in one afternoon.

See Criterion C: personal engagement for what examiners look for.

Which course is it for?

CourseFitMaths to lean on
AA SLGood fitEstimating match probabilities from results; Exact probability for small knockout brackets (tree diagrams)
AA HLGood fitEstimating match probabilities from results; Exact probability for small knockout brackets (tree diagrams)
AI SLGood fitEstimating match probabilities from results; Exact probability for small knockout brackets (tree diagrams)
AI HLGood fitEstimating match probabilities from results; Exact probability for small knockout brackets (tree diagrams)

Level: Solid. Needs some independent work beyond class examples. See how the IA differs between AA and AI, SL and HL.

How this idea reaches the top bands

Reflection (D)

For this idea, start with the weak points: probabilities that ignore draws or home advantage without comment; and too few simulated tournaments. Say how each one affects your answer.

Use of mathematics (E)

SL: estimating match probabilities from results; exact probability for small knockout brackets (tree diagrams); simulation of full tournaments; comparing proportions; HL: confidence intervals; effect of seeding and two-legged ties, each explained in your own words and carried out correctly.

How simulation explorations reach the top bands in general: Simulation & Monte Carlo methods IA ideas. Guides: A · B · C · D · E · self-grade sheet.

Taking it further

Model team strengths with an Elo rating and simulate a whole season, or find the format that maximises excitement as well as fairness.

Extending it for HL

Add an HL technique the question genuinely needs: what an HL simulation exploration adds.

Frequently asked questions

Which IB Maths course is this IA idea for?

It works for AI SL, AI HL, AA SL and AA HL. We rate it Solid: it needs some independent work beyond class examples.

What mathematics does this IA use?

Estimating match probabilities from results, exact probability for small knockout brackets (tree diagrams), simulation of full tournaments, comparing proportions; HL: confidence intervals and effect of seeding and two-legged ties.

Where can I get data for this IA?

Download a season of results from Football-Data.co.uk or a sport you follow and estimate team strengths. Checked sources and tools: Football-Data.co.uk and Desmos graphing calculator.

Turn this idea into your IA

The planner opens with “Does the best team win? Knockout cups versus leagues” filled in: the question, the maths and the data sources.

Plan this IA free

Your plan is kept in this browser. A free account keeps it with your drafts on any device: Join free · Sign in

Also: free IA self-check · A–E checklist (PDF) · have a draft? AI feedback or a review with Pete (€100)

Writing it up: how to write a Maths IA, step by step · structure and format · mistakes that cost marks · IA modelling, step by step

Similar ideas

All simulation ideas · AI SL ideas · AI HL ideas · AA SL ideas · AA HL ideas · All 239 IA ideas